105 evaluations
Mischief scores just above the calibration floor because its infinite canvas and real-time collaboration layer introduce a mild social pull (will a collaborator…
Nicotine scores extremely high on speed — its 7-second CNS delivery is class-leading — and strong on solitude and bottomlessness via physiological lock-in and f…
Hinge lands just above Amazon (72) and meaningfully below Instagram (93), which is the right neighborhood. The like-cap friction and slower profile-reading cade…
Sophiie.ai scores well above utility products and mainstream social platforms primarily because the solitude and bottomlessness features are operating at near-m…
Fishing sits just above SMS (38) and near email (42) in the calibration table, which feels right: it shares the variable-ratio reinforcement architecture that m…
Boxing scores near the utility-product tier of the calibration anchors despite being genuinely compelling as a pursuit. What pulls the score up is the authentic…
UFC consumption sits close to the bom.com.au–Kindle band on the calibration scale — it is a time-bounded, socially-consumed, scheduled media product with genuin…
AFL scores modestly and roughly in the zone of bom.com.au, though for different structural reasons. Its strongest pull is the medium-speed arousal cadence of li…
Pokémon GO scores meaningfully below pure screen-based social platforms like Instagram (93) or Facebook (88) because the physical-world requirement is a genuine…
Beer scores above SMS and Email but below Facebook, sitting in a band with WhatsApp and CNN. What pulls it up is the bottomless supply environment of modern ret…
Ice cream scores meaningfully above pure utility tools like macOS Notes but sits well below any social or algorithmic platform. Its addictive pull is entirely s…
This score sits just below SMS (38) in the calibration table, which feels appropriate: both products deliver variable reward through discrete notifications and …
Urauto.ai scores near the floor of the calibration scale, sitting just below the Kindle anchor (12) and above macOS Notes (4). What keeps it from the absolute f…
Athly sits in roughly the same band as SMS or Email on the calibration scale — present variable reward and solitude, but structurally bounded in ways that preve…
Whispa-type anonymous secret-sharing platforms score meaningfully above mainstream social media like Facebook (88 would be a ceiling here given lower production…
Claude lands well below social media platforms and meaningfully below even SMS (38), primarily because it is pull-based, response-gated, and non-algorithmic. Th…
This product sits just above the absolute floor established by macOS Notes (4), nudged up marginally by the one-shot curiosity loop of "what score will it give?…
WSJ scores well below general-interest social and entertainment platforms because three of its four features are substantially inert or weak. Its content is art…
This site scores just above the absolute floor, marginally above macOS Notes (4) only because a corporate website introduces a faint human-paced variable reward…
LinkedIn sits meaningfully above Amazon (72) and is in the same tier, though its professional framing and slower content cadence prevent it from climbing to Fac…
PostHog sits just above the calibration anchor for bom.com.au (18) — both are utility-first, data-driven tools with a defined page structure and no entertainmen…
Flashback scores below SMS (38) and sits closer to the utility end of the scale, held down primarily by its slow speed and finite, self-supplied content pool. W…
The ATO website scores near the floor of the scale, sitting just above a pure offline utility like macOS Notes (4) only because sessions are typically solitary …
xplainable.io sits at the extreme low end of the addictiveness spectrum, landing just below the **Kindle calibration anchor (12)** and roughly comparable to **m…
TikTok is the reference implementation of this framework — it scores at or near Maximum on every single dimension simultaneously, which no other general-audienc…
Blurred Minds scores near the bottom of the scale, sitting just above macOS Notes (4) and Kindle (12), and well below even passive utility sites like bom.com.au…
GTA Online in particular is a well-engineered compulsion loop that scores comparably to Amazon (72) and nudges toward Facebook territory (88) for dedicated onli…
Reddit lands comfortably above Facebook in raw score potential but below Instagram in practice, which maps to its mechanics. It nearly matches Instagram on Bott…
This tool scores below even macOS Notes on most dimensions, kept from the absolute floor only by the mild novelty-seeking that any generative AI response produc…
This score sits just above the calibration floor occupied by macOS Notes (4), reflecting only the marginal reality that any website with a browser back-button a…
LinkedIn sits meaningfully above CNN (48) and WhatsApp (52) but well below Facebook (88), held back primarily by its slower speed cadence and the inherent frict…
Grindr scores meaningfully above general social media utilities but below the reference-maximum platforms like Instagram and TikTok. What pulls it up is the com…
Saje.app scores near the low end of the scale, sitting just above the Kindle calibration anchor (12) and well below utility news sites like bom.com.au (18). Wha…
Shark Week scores well below social-media anchors because it fails to activate its two most important features — speed and teasing — at meaningful intensity. It…
TapSpot sits in roughly the same band as WhatsApp (52) and above CNN (48), pulled upward by its likely variable-match reward structure and algorithmically refre…
This is a near-inert product under the framework — it sits just above a plain text file by virtue of having a contact form (a single discrete action with a real…
Oscorp Energy lands just above the calibration anchors for pure utility products like macOS Notes (4) and Kindle (12), and in the vicinity of bom.com.au (18). W…
Avataari.ai's addictiveness profile resembles a more immersive, personalized version of email or SMS — solitary, bottomless in principle, with conversational va…
This product scores at the low end of the scale, sitting just above the Kindle (12) and slightly below bom.com.au (18) as a reference. What pushes it above bare…
Replenix.ai scores just below the Kindle calibration anchor because its design intent actively works against the four features rather than with them. Solitude i…
This score sits below even macOS Notes on most dimensions because at least Notes is used repeatedly as a utility habit — Oscorp Energy's website is a destinatio…
This product scores at the floor of the calibration scale, matching macOS Notes as a pure utility object with no behaviorally engineered retention mechanics. Wh…
YouTube scores just below Instagram (93) and TikTok (97) because its dominant long-form format slows the feedback cadence relative to those reference implementa…
Paddock Map scores just below Kindle on the calibration scale, and for similar structural reasons: it is a finite, utility-first tool with no algorithmic engine…
Techhorizon.academy, evaluated as a conventional structured learning platform, scores near the utility end of the scale — comparable to **bom.com.au (18)** in t…
DueToday.ai scores near the floor of the scale, sitting just above macOS Notes (4) because it introduces a mild completion-reward loop (checking off tasks) and …
Pizza scores in the low utility range — above macOS Notes because it does carry neurochemical reward mechanics that are non-trivial, but well below any digital …
Chicken schnitzel scores just above the macOS Notes floor because it does deliver a genuine sensory reward loop — taste and satiation are real reinforcers — and…
MAFS sits meaningfully above general news (CNN, ~48) and approaches but does not reach social-platform territory. Its score is anchored by a powerful teasing ar…
South Park sits just above SMS and Email in the calibration stack, driven primarily by its massive bottomless catalog and autoplay delivery on streaming platfor…
The Simpsons scores well below the social-media tier of products because three of its four features are structurally weak. Bottomlessness is its strongest dimen…
Hooning scores comparably to WhatsApp (52) but via a completely different feature profile: it is fast and physically absorbing where WhatsApp is social and vari…
Fireworks score just below the Kindle calibration anchor, and for similar structural reasons: the experience is finite, externally paced, and socially embedded.…
Mexican food scores meaningfully above pure utility tools (macOS Notes at 4) because the chip basket bottomlessness and the fast-cadence finger-food format are …
SXSW's score is pulled upward primarily by its bottomless programming architecture and its authentic FOMO-driven variable-reward structure — attending always me…
Startup Daily scores only modestly above pure utility products because it is fundamentally a trade publication with editorial structure rather than a behavioral…
Hacker News scores meaningfully above pure utility tools and commodity news sites, landing just above CNN (48) and below WhatsApp (52–55 range) — though the com…
Hacker News sits just below email on the calibration scale, which is the right neighborhood. Its strongest axis is solitude — the stereotypical late-night engin…
Antler.co scores below even the macOS Notes calibration anchor in practice, though it edges above it marginally because the portfolio directory and blog create …
Xero scores below the Kindle calibration anchor and sits near macOS Notes territory, held up only slightly by its task-completion micro-satisfactions (reconcili…
Tinder scores well above mid-range anchors because it deploys genuine variable-ratio reward architecture — the same probabilistic engine that powers slot machin…
Rice scores marginally above macOS Notes (4) only because eating does carry a mild hedonic reward signal and the warm-pot availability scenario introduces a fai…
The score sits just below SMS in the calibration table, which is appropriate: Harry Potter's pull is driven almost entirely by serialized narrative momentum and…
Harry Potter scores meaningfully below digital social products because two of the four features are largely inert. The content is finite, the speed is slow, and…
National holidays score near the absolute floor of the framework, sitting below even macOS Notes on most features because Notes is at least a solitary activity.…
Lasagna scores below even macOS Notes on several dimensions, saved only from a floor score by the modest compulsive potential of palatable food in general — str…
Vaping scores exceptionally high on the three mechanistic features — solitude, bottomlessness, and speed — and in fact *exceeds* TikTok on raw speed of reward d…
Smoking scores surprisingly high for a non-digital product, driven almost entirely by the extraordinary speed of nicotine delivery and the self-regenerating bot…
Dilbert sits just above the Kindle anchor (12) and well below SMS (38). What pushes it slightly above Kindle is the theoretically bottomless archive and the mil…
Job interviews score meaningfully on teasing alone — the variable-ratio reinforcement of opaque human judgment and the near-miss phenomenology of ambiguous soci…
Spin the Bottle scores near the bottom of the scale because three of the four features are either inert or actively reversed. The group setting demolishes Solit…
Craps lands just above Amazon and meaningfully below Facebook, which is the right neighborhood for a live casino table game with genuine social friction as its …
Blackjack scores meaningfully high across all four features, though it falls short of Facebook or Instagram because its teasing mechanism is less algorithmicall…
D&D scores just above the calibration anchors for pure utility tools, primarily because the dice mechanics introduce genuine variable reward and the campaign st…
Stamp collecting scores above pure utility tools like macOS Notes (4) primarily because of its genuine bottomlessness and the scarcity-driven variable reward of…
Wood scores below even macOS Notes on most dimensions, landing it near the theoretical floor of the scale. What tiny score it earns comes from mild solitude and…
Perplexity lands just above SMS (38) and below email (42) in the calibration range, which reflects its core nature: it is primarily a utility with bounded inter…
ChatGPT sits meaningfully above utility tools like email (42) and CNN (48) but well below social platforms like Facebook (88) or Instagram (93). The product's s…
ChatGPT sits just above SMS and Email in the calibration stack — it shares their variable-reward-of-the-incoming-message quality, but replaces human social stak…
Duolingo scores well above general utility apps and comfortably above social messaging products, sitting just above Amazon (72) in the calibration table. What e…
Pornography on a major streaming platform scores just below Instagram and near Facebook on this framework, but is pulled toward the ceiling by two features oper…
Chocolate scores meaningfully above a pure utility tool like macOS Notes (4) because it delivers a real, fast, repeatable hedonic reward with low friction and m…
Working from home scores meaningfully below SMS (38) because it lacks the social variable-reward intensity of an active messaging thread, and its feedback caden…
Office work scores above pure utility tools like macOS Notes (4) because the inbox does carry genuine variable-reward structure and the task queue is genuinely …
Baseball scores well below the digital calibration anchors because it fails to weaponize three of the four features. Solitude is low, speed is very low, and tea…
Cricket scores below SMS and email on this framework, primarily because three of its four features are constrained by the sport's physical and social architectu…
The NRL product sits close to the CNN/WhatsApp band of the calibration scale — emotionally charged and capable of producing sustained engagement, but structural…
Corn scores marginally above macOS Notes (4) only because certain preparations — salted popcorn in a large bag, for instance — introduce modest compulsive consu…
At 98, gambling apps represent the ceiling of the framework in current consumer products. The score exceeds TikTok's 97 by one point for a specific reason: real…
TikTok at 97 is the reference implementation of the four-feature framework in consumer software. It achieves Maximum on all four dimensions simultaneously — som…
Instagram at 93 is the near-maximum implementation of the framework. It is held just below TikTok's 97 because the social graph still grounds some content in de…
Facebook at 88 hits all four features strongly. The gap between Facebook and Instagram at 93 is explained by format: Instagram's visual-first, Reels-heavy desig…
Amazon at 72 scores above eBay despite no auctions because the addictive mechanics are more consistently applied across every session — not just during peak auc…
eBay at 68 is the highest-scoring marketplace because auction mechanics import literal gambling architecture. The combination of near-miss (outbid), variable re…
Fox News scores 55 vs CNN's 48 for two reasons: heavier reliance on short video segments (speed) and more emotionally acute content framing (teasing). The gap i…
WhatsApp at 52 sits above SMS at 38 precisely because Meta has layered social and algorithmic features onto what began as a pure messaging tool. The gap will li…
CNN at 48 represents the doomscrolling news archetype. Emotional headlines are a real teasing mechanic, but the article-based format and limited personalization…
Email scores 42 — just above SMS — because the inbox structure (unread counts, badges, promotional tabs) adds more teasing scaffolding than raw SMS. The compuls…
At 38, SMS sits well below messaging apps with algorithmic layers. The variable reward of incoming messages is real but operates at human pace with human limits…
Scores slightly above Kindle because the radar loop introduces a minor speed element and the site is checked repeatedly throughout the day (habitual access). Bu…
Scores 12 rather than 4 because the catalog and store introduce mild bottomlessness, and long reading sessions can produce flow states. But engagement here is q…
The baseline for "not addictive." Notes scores 4 because it hits solitude (private use) but that feature is inert without any compulsive consumption mechanics. …
LinkedIn scores above Amazon (72) and slightly below Facebook (88), which is the right neighborhood. The profile-view tease mechanic is among the most precisely…
Netflix scores meaningfully above general web browsing or email but sits well below Facebook or Instagram because Speed is its structural weak point — the long-…
LinkedIn sits above email and WhatsApp but well below Facebook and Instagram. Its professional framing suppresses solitude somewhat and its text-heavy content f…