⚡Addictiveness Evaluator/About

The science behind the score

This tool applies a research-grounded framework for diagnosing how addictive any digital product is — drawn from 15 years of field research into gambling machine design and its migration into mainstream consumer software.

Where this framework comes from

NYU anthropologist Natasha Dow Schüll spent 15 years embedded in Las Vegas casinos studying what makes video slot machines so compulsive. Her landmark 2012 book, Addiction by Design, identified four structural features — solitude, bottomlessness, speed, and teasing — that together produce what she calls the "machine zone": a dissociative state where players lose track of time, physical sensation, and the outside world.

By the early 2010s, those same four features had quietly migrated from the casino floor into mainstream apps. The transition wasn't accidental — behavioral design drew explicitly on gambling research. Social media feeds, short-form video, algorithmic recommendation, and infinite scroll are all engineering implementations of the same psychological architecture Schüll documented in slot machines.

Jonathan D. Morrow, neuroscientist and psychiatrist at the University of Michigan, extended this work into digital products, identifying the teasing mechanic — withholding the exact reward users seek — as the most potent individual feature in driving compulsive use.

Source: Michaeleen Doucleff, NPR (April 21, 2026) · Addiction by Design, Natasha Dow Schüll (Princeton University Press, 2012)

The four features

Every evaluation scores a product across these four dimensions. They compound — products that hit all four simultaneously are dramatically more addictive than products that hit only one. TikTok is the reference implementation of all four at maximum intensity.

01

Solitude

When a product is used alone, the social cues that would naturally signal it's time to stop are removed. A friend saying 'you've been on that for hours' doesn't exist when the screen is your only company. Schüll found this was a critical risk multiplier for slot machine addiction; the same dynamic applies to phone-in-bed social media use. Studies find that children who regularly use screens alone in their bedrooms show significantly higher rates of problematic use.

"When the relationship is just between you and the machine, it removes social cues needed for stopping. It's harder to notice when the activity no longer serves the person playing or scrolling."— Natasha Dow Schüll
02

Bottomlessness

There is no natural stopping point. Infinite scroll, autoplay, algorithmically refreshed feeds, 24/7 availability — the user never reaches a 'you're done' state. A book ends. A casino never closes and a TikTok feed never empties. Without a natural endpoint, the only stopping cue is the user's own willpower, which is exactly what addictive design is engineered to erode.

"There's no natural stopping point. So you never feel finished or satisfied. You want one more of something, endlessly."— Natasha Dow Schüll
03

Speed

The faster the feedback loop — action, reward, next action — the harder it is to disengage. Schüll documented this in slot machine research: faster spin rates correlated directly with longer sessions and deeper losses. The same effect applies digitally. Higher-speed internet, infinite scroll, and short-form video all accelerated the feedback cadence of consumer apps into the zone where dissociation occurs.

"The speed of the feedback can cause this sense that you merge with the screen. You don't know where you begin and the machine ends. The speed really just pulls you into this flow."— Natasha Dow Schüll
04

Teasing

The most important feature, per Morrow. The algorithm learns precisely what you want — and then withholds it, feeding you something close but not quite. You keep searching. The reward that would satisfy you is always just out of reach. This is the digital descendant of slot-machine near-miss engineering: the reel that stops one symbol short of the jackpot, programmed to appear more often than random chance would produce.

"Apps don't give it to you. They give you something close to that, and then a few clicks later, the algorithm gives you something even closer. They give just enough to keep you engaged, keep you looking at the app and interacting with it as long as possible."— Jonathan D. Morrow, University of Michigan

Legal and policy context

In 2025–2026, two landmark US court cases found Meta and Google liable for harming children, with prosecutors explicitly characterising the platforms as "digital casinos." Both companies are appealing. Regulatory research in Australia, the UK, and several US states has documented that social casino app users show problem-gambling patterns at rates comparable to or exceeding real-money gamblers.

Children are identified as especially vulnerable in this research — not because apps are designed specifically to target them, but because children have less developed capacity for self-regulation against design that has been professionally engineered to exploit that gap in adults.

How the 1–100 score works

Each product is rated across the four features on a qualitative scale (None → Maximum). The final score is calibrated against a fixed set of anchor products — from macOS Notes at 4 to PokerStars at 98 — so that scores are internally consistent rather than arbitrary.

ScoreProductCharacteristic
4macOS NotesBaseline — utility with no feed or algorithm
38SMSHuman-paced variable reward only
52WhatsAppMessaging + algorithmic layers
68eBayAuction mechanics = gambling architecture
72AmazonBottomless catalog + one-click friction removal
88FacebookAll four features at high intensity
93InstagramFour parallel infinite surfaces
97TikTokReference implementation — Maximum on all four
98PokerStarsTikTok + real financial stakes

Disclaimer. This tool is a structured analytical framework, not a mental-health assessment, a legal opinion, or a regulatory determination. Scores are diagnostic, not verdicts — a product can score 97 and still be useful to an individual. Individual susceptibility to addictive design varies significantly. If you are concerned about your own or a child's relationship with a digital product, consult a qualified health professional.

Framework: Natasha Dow Schüll, Addiction by Design (Princeton University Press, 2012) · Jonathan D. Morrow, University of Michigan